Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
电影整体及格，啥事都有。但敢于自揭伤疤，敢拍，敢演，值得佩服。
平平无奇到连结局反转都没有一点感觉。不过看了评论居然还有人拿“资本家操纵”来评价韩国的，下次排队被棉签操纵的时候捅一捅小脑仁吧。
断断续续地看完了，有点尬又有点戳，继续dream一个官摄。无论如何，我还是喜欢Ben Platt和DEH的
电影本身当然很一般，剧本表演都有不同问题，但看到最后也不会觉得浪费了2个小时，因为电影是另一种形式的记录。那个说自己是英国国籍所以不在乎死几个韩国人的韩国人，那些直到最后都不觉得自己有错的政府部门负责人，呵呵。要记录。要记住。
结局反转，我还以为那个男的哭是因为好不容易升官了紧接着就完蛋了😂
2022-5-22 00:18:22 黑水。托夜班都比你好看
棒子真的敢拍，这个世界还有很多东西都是资本在操控运作，只是没人敢提或者提了石沉大海罢了。题材很好，内容很闷，包括中间的反转，本是反派的李突然化身奇异博士，只有一种办法能赢，显得有点仓促，最后十分钟的政客之间互相推诿也是点睛之笔，凸显了本片平民与资本的战争。但很多东西过于的理想化，以及中间调查取证的博弈，并没有太多去烘托那种绝望的气氛，让这片不及另外几部真实事件改编的韩国片。
刚失去亲人坚决抵制涉事商家，坚持要法庭告赢时：“我不要你的臭钱！你以为你的钱就能买人命吗？他们能活过来吗？”涉事商家公布和解名单（有赔偿金）时：“怎么办，人死了我一分钱也没拿到”
真的好烂…为了看现场补的课，点开三次都没能看完
He said, you looked very pretty…uhh it looks pretty cool when you put indigo straights in your hair
说来还是第一次在这边去电影院，
每个人看过才会有自己的体会，对于我来说是十分难得的治愈旅程
加湿器、除湿器，空气过滤器，这些人类越来越依赖的东西，真的是可以杀人于无形！我们应该多点接触大自然，少用电器。本人喜欢韩国片，思维缜密，机构清新，永远会给人意想不到的惊喜
观看的资源最后一段字幕没翻译，导致不清楚最后这事是什么结局。看片名以为是个惊悚悬疑故事，没想到是韩国影片里常见的批判政府和大企业议题的电影。拍得也很套路，除了最后听证会上各个国家行政机构的甩锅有点意思外，其他也没太多新意。既然连自己身边有亲人因此去世的受害者家属都能被利益左右，你难道指望黑心资本家自己良心发现自己承认错误，承担这巨额的损失？剧情可笑就在于利益集团拼命公关洗白，却找了个同样家里有人因该使用产品导致生病离世的律师来负责处理这些事，这编剧强行给反派降智也是没谁了。这也导致本片虽然在揭示韩国社会阴暗面，却总觉得很不真实。还不如现实中网络维权来得有效。
韩版黑水，多年之后希望不要有什么消毒湿巾的黑料曝出来
绝望里的反转，大快人心，也让人明白善恶到头终有报，正义可能会迟到，但绝不会缺席
理想化的设定太多有点脱离真实感，但总体还是可以. 他们蒙住了我们的嘴，但韩国至少还有电影.
电影来讲很一般，最重要的是改编自真实事件那一行字。真正的英雄。
不是取材真实事件就是好电影，叙事故事的逻辑和内容也很重要。
毕竟财阀真的有能力把所有人都收买了，在金钱的诱惑下可能很多人都经不起诱惑。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
