Min Ji-suk runs a "ticket bar"where customers can purchase tickets for certain "services"in the town of Sokcho in Gangwon-do. She hires Miss Yang (Ahn So-young), Miss Hong (Lee Hye-young), and Se-young (Jeon Se-young) through the employment agency. Miss Yang and Miss Hong, who are well experienced in this type of business, are used to accepting propositions from customers. But Se-young, who is dating a college student named Min-su, rejects all requests for sexual favors. When Min-su professes to having problems with his tuition and finances, Se-young reassures him that she will procure the necessary funds for him. When the bar's clientele begins to dwindle because of Se-young, Ji-suk reprimands her severely. Se-young develops a close relationship with a Captain Pak and even allows him to sleep with her. She asks Captain Pak to find Min-su employment on a boat, but when Min-su comes to Sokcho for his new job, he sees how Se-young has been making her living. Shocked, he turns his back on the job and leaves. When he eventually returns to Sokcho, he scathingly denounces Se-young's morality and severs their relationship. Decades ago, Ji-suk had stumbled into the bar business in a desperate effort to support her husband, who was serving time in prison; she later left him voluntarily out of shame and moral degradation. Concerned that Se-young will end up with the same fate, Ji-suk asks Min-su to meet with her. She begs him not to abandon Se-young, but he flatly refuses. Ji-suk reacts by pushing Min-su into the sea, and suffers a mental breakdown that lands her in a psychiatric institution.
其实是一个很严肃的话题。站在寄养家庭、警长儿子和主角身上都能理解各自的心境、处境。饶恕（forgive）意味着和解，这种痛彻心扉的感觉很难站在一个轻飘飘地旁人视角感受得到。另外，很不喜欢一些肤浅的戏谑评论“冲奥片”“拿奖片”。
幼儿犯罪不是无罪吗？... 反转得有点意思 演技、化妆厉害了👍
大冤+大爱，这是全人类共通的戏剧主题。很感人，桑德拉布洛克的表演很高级，把这份忍辱负重刻画得入木三分，谜底揭开的点也恰到好处，停止在姐妹相拥简直是太明智的选择，干净利落，余音绕梁。
没人关心受害者及受害者家属，包括旁观者和施暴者。通常地，所有人的视角里没有受害者，没有受害者家属。
值得奥斯卡最佳音效奖和最佳音效剪辑奖提名，和去年的《金属之声》一样声音细节音效层次感太强了！故事还是偏简单偏老套了，前面节奏太慢，后面还行。桑德拉•布洛克表演也还行，不过份量还是不够啊！
桑德拉布洛克演技太赞。这故事其实也无解，饶恕从来就是件很难的事情。
3.5星，前半部分故事有多引人入胜，结尾就有多庸俗潦草
不要轻看每一个人，你根本不知道ta背后有多少你无法想象的故事。
好棒！题材和演技都非常好。大家都有自己的桎梏，只有和自己和解，才能安心地活下去。
gravity 后有一阵子没见Sandra Bullock了，毕竟老演员，演技有保证，姐妹相会回忆杀红了我的眼眶
还有人说节奏慢，这节奏不慢，真不慢，很稳当，该讲的都讲了，不该讲的反正也差不多了，就是没铺开，铺开就更长了。电影讲成这样，可以了。
为了保护她5岁的妹妹，我还在想是什么样的情形会让她杀了警长，原来不是她开的枪（剧透）。整部戏的节奏不快，冲突也不算激烈，但表达出来的情绪却是很到位，那种无奈和抓狂，绝望和期待，桑德拉真是演得太好了。我不禁想到一个，就是如果当年说实话，会是什么样的判法呢？
又是Sandra的一次影后级的表演。高潮在最后。
What happened to that cop killer? life goes on… 编剧选题真是不能更niche… 毫不扭捏的视听盛宴！ 极端饱满的人物刻画、无微不至到每一个音符和妆容的细节
5/10。除了桑德拉布洛克的演技是真的好，实在讨厌这部片子的方方面面。
故事不错，演技更没得挑，只是节奏偏慢了一些，但可能再快的话就不够细腻和震撼了，根据美剧改编的，原版的剧集应该不错。
拍得细腻，桑姐演得细腻。 // 比较典型的生活化悬疑，露丝冲老家之前我还真没想过是这种发展。 // 被保护得那么好的妹妹，有没有些当今美国人的影子？ // 结尾妹妹要是不认识露丝就好了……哎呀我真残忍。 // PS 又是一部没有人错的电影，那到底谁错了呢？
情绪的叠进，最终释放恰到好处。偶尔瑕疵虽然也存在。
Sandra Bullock傻大姐蜕变为演技派啊
是那种“说好不好说坏不坏让人没有评价欲望”的片子。话说基努当年是爱着（过）桑姐吧？
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
